Lux in Tenebris
At age 12, hottie Jackson Brown was seduced and sodomized by his 16-year-old cousin while they showered together.
He liked it.
For the next two years they were occasional lovers, until, camping one night, Jack smothered him, burned their lodgings, and sustained minor burns to his hands as proof he'd tried to help.
Ten years later, seminary graduate Father Brown was assigned to a remote parish where he resumed his evil ways.
Over the next 35 years he lost track of the number of children he'd buggered and forced to fellate him, his Church conveniently moving him in dicey times.
Superiors suspected he may have killed the dozen gone missing in that period, but lacking evidence, shrugged it off.
Sent back to Boston, Jack lured two angelic-looking lads, Mario and Damian, into his lair, buying their silence with vague salvation promises and cheap ecumenical trinkets. Damian was especially winsome with his blue eyes, clear skin and shock of red hair.
Following a late Eucharist, Jack continued to imbibe in the potent sacramental wine back in his quarters. His reverie was interrupted by a timid knock at the door. Lurching to open it, he was pleased to see Damian there.
Reseated, he raised his cassock as the boy kneeled before him.
Then, horrified, watched as the shapeshifting transpired.
The sharp-toothed demon seemed to smirk.
"Time to meet your unMaker, Jack."
It then ripped him to shreds.
Before it reverted back to "Damian", its teeth shone... like a light in the darkness.